Glucosamine - Does it work?

This one's for you  Pete...

Recently a friend of mine screwed up his knee by "4-wheeling". After surgery and months of rehab he is finally back to attempting to golf. While we were golfing last week he asked me about glucosamine. Apparently his doctor is recommending he take the supplement. I told him a client of mine was in a University of Penn study a couple of years ago where they had patients on glucosamine,chondroitin, glucosamine with chondroitin, celebrex and a placebo. The results showed no significant difference between the groups (slightly better for glucosamine with chondroitin)[For a copy of that article showing the results, click here]. But I decided to do some more research and found the following on the Mayo Clinic's web site. The information appears to have positive results combining glucosamine with sulfate. Please read on and devise your own opinion. I will give you my opinion at the end of the article.

Here it is...

"Glucosamine is a natural compound that is found in healthy cartilage. Glucosamine sulfate is a normal constituent of glycoaminoglycans in cartilage matrix and synovial fluid.

Available evidence from randomized controlled trials supports the use of glucosamine sulfate in the treatment of osteoarthritis, particularly of the knee. It is believed that the sulfate moiety provides clinical benefit in the synovial fluid by strengthening cartilage and aiding glycosaminoglycan synthesis. If this hypothesis is confirmed, it would mean that only the glucosamine sulfate form is effective and non-sulfated glucosamine forms are not effective. Glucosamine is commonly taken in combination with chondroitin, a glycosaminoglycan derived from articular cartilage. Use of complementary therapies, including glucosamine, is common in patients with osteoarthritis, and may allow for reduced doses of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory agents.

The following uses have been tested in humans or animals. Safety and effectiveness have not always been proven. Some of these conditions are potentially serious, and should be evaluated by a qualified healthcare provider.

Knee osteoarthritis (mild-to-moderate)
Based on human research, there is good evidence to support the use of glucosamine sulfate in the treatment of mild-to-moderate knee osteoarthritis. Most studies have used glucosamine sulfate supplied by one European manufacturer (Rotta Research Laboratorium), and it is not known if glucosamine preparations made by other manufacturers are equally effective. Results of a recent large clinical trial (GAIT) comparing the effects of glucosamine to celecoxib (Celebrex(r)) for treatment of knee osteoarthritis have yet to be published. A recent study or postmenopausal women found that glucosamine reduced joint space narrowing compared to placebo treatment. Although some studies of glucosamine have not found benefits, these have either included patients with severe osteoarthritis, or used products other than glucosamine sulfate . The evidence for the effect of glycosaminoglycan polysulphate is conflicting and merits further investigation. More well-designed clinical trials are needed to confirm safety and effectiveness, and to test different formulations of glucosamine.

Osteoarthritis (general)
Several human studies and animal experiments report benefits of glucosamine in treating osteoarthritis of various joints of the body, although the evidence is less plentiful than that for knee osteoarthritis. Some of these benefits include pain relief, possibly due to an anti-inflammatory effect of glucosamine, and improved joint function. Overall, these studies have not been well designed. Analyses, which group the existing studies together and isolate higher-quality research (meta-analyses) have found conflicting results, with improvement in some scales measuring pain and disability, but not in others. Although there is some promising research, more study is needed in this area before a firm conclusion can be made.

The below doses are based on scientific research, publications, traditional use, or expert opinion. Many herbs and supplements have not been thoroughly tested, and safety and effectiveness may not be proven. Brands may be made differently, with variable ingredients, even within the same brand. The below doses may not apply to all products. You should read product labels, and discuss doses with a qualified healthcare provider before starting therapy.

Adults (18 yrs. or older) - Osteoarthritis : In most available studies, 500 milligrams of glucosamine sulfate has been used, taken by mouth as tablets or capsules three times daily, for 30 to 90 days. Once daily dosing as 1.5 grams (1500 milligrams) has also been used. Limited research has used 1500 milligrams daily as a crystalline powder for oral solution, or 500 milligrams of glucosamine hydrochloride three times daily. Dosing of 20 milligrams per kilogram of body weight daily has also been recommended in some publications. One study used a dose of 2000 milligrams per day for 12 weeks.

Side Effects and Warnings
In most human studies, glucosamine sulfate at a dose of 500 milligrams three times daily (tablets or capsules) has been well tolerated for 30 to 90 days. In a three-year study and several short-term trials, the number of adverse events in patients taking glucosamine was no different from placebo (sugar pill). There have been reports that in laboratory animals, doses as high as 5000 milligrams per kilogram taken by mouth, 3000 milligrams per kilogram injected into muscle, and 1500 milligrams per kilogram through the veins have not caused death.

Side effects may include upset stomach, drowsiness, insomnia, headache, skin reactions, sun sensitivity, and nail toughening. There are rare reports of abdominal pain, loss of appetite, vomiting, nausea, flatulence (gas), constipation, heartburn, and diarrhea. Based on several human cases, temporary increases in blood pressure and heart rate, as well as palpitations may occur with glucosamine/chondroitin products. Based on animal research, glucosamine theoretically may increase the risk for eye cataract formation.

It remains unclear if glucosamine alters blood sugar levels. Several human studies suggest no effects on blood sugar, while other research reports effects on insulin.
"

My opinion is that it appears that glucosamine with sulfate has a beneficial effect on knee osteoarthritis and a mild effect on osteoarthritis. As always, I highly recommend before you start taking a supplement you speak with your physician. I also went on GNC's web site and found that there are dozens of different types of glucosamine available. Again, get the recommendation from your physician as to which is best for you, not the recommendation of the sales clerk at the vitamin store. In this case, more is not better; you don't need to take a supplement with 3-4-5 additives in it if it is not necessary.

Discussion: Have you or are you currently taking any form of glucosamine? What results are you finding?

For a full copy of the above article on mayoclinic.com click here...
http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/glucosamine/NS_patient-glucosamine

 

What did you think of this article?




Trackbacks
  • No trackbacks exist for this entry.
Comments

  • 8/14/2007 8:01 PM O. MEDFORD wrote:
    I HAVE BEEN USING 1500 mg. GLUCOSAMINE HYDROCHLORIDE TWICE A DAY FOR THE LAST 5 MONTHS AND MY KNEE PAIN HAS DISAPEERED. THE GLUCOSAMINE ALSO HAS 1500 mg. MSM AND IS MANUFACTURED BY SCHIFF.
    Reply to this
    1. 8/14/2007 8:13 PM Steve Uhlenbrock wrote:

      I'm glad it has been working for you. I believe MSM is a form of sulfate. In fact when I was researching today I found the following article on WebMD that is perfect for your situation.

      Here it is...

      "Many people with arthritis -- especially osteoarthritis -- use supplements in their diet to ease the pain of arthritis. Glucosamine and chondroitin are the most well-known and best tested. Methyl sulfonylmethane (MSM) is another supplement used to ease the pain of arthritis, but it has not been through as much rigorous scientific testing."

      And here is the web address for this citing. (
      http://www.webmd.com/osteoarthritis/guide/arthritis-supplements)

      Also, click on this link to find out possible interactions with other medications. (http://www.webmd.com/drugs/drug-64167-MSM+Glucosamine+Complex+Oral.aspx?drugid=64167&drugname=MSM+Glucosamine+Complex+Oral&pagenumber=7)


      Reply to this
  • 8/15/2007 8:09 AM Donna Marie Desfor wrote:
    I have been taking Mona Vie Active (with glucosamine) for 3 weeks now. The difference in my joints and recovery time in my work outs is amazing. At 44 years old, and a relatively active lifestyle I was becoming very disenchanted at the gym feeling like I was losing ground instead of improving, especially in my weightlifting -- which is so important to me, my metabolism and my overall health. Since I started with the Mona Vie Active my recovery time from work outs is back to a normal 1 or 2 days max!!! and I'm able to workout with more regularity, increasing my weights and increasing the number of days in the gym! I sleep better and my skin looks great despite the beating it takes in the summer with pool and beach time! Look at www.Monavie.com to get the whole scoop, including the part about the glucosamine in the Active formula. If anyone is interested in trying it out, let me know. I did and am loving the benefits.
    Reply to this
Leave a comment

Submitted comments will be subject to moderation before being displayed.

 Enter the above security code (required)

 Name

 Email (will not be published)

 Website

Your comment is 0 characters limited to 3000 characters.